Return Asymmetry Effect in Commodity Futures

Theoretical studies show that the greater (lower) upside asymmetry is associated with lower (higher) expected returns. Wu, Zhu, and Chen (2020) examined return asymmetry in the Chinese stock market with a new distribution-based asymmetry measure (IE) of Jiang et al. (2020) that uses the difference between upside and downside return probabilities to capture the degree of asymmetry. Consistent with the theory, they have found that the average value-weighted return spread between the highest and lowest IE decile is -0.81% per month. This novel study builds upon the previous research and expands an asymmetric measure IE to the new asset class. The paper examines various long-short commodity portfolios and studies the best-performing portfolio in detail. Overall, almost all studied portfolios exhibit statistically significant and economically large returns. Besides, the correlation analysis has shown that the asymmetry-based portfolios are related to the skewness effect, but these two anomalies are distinct. Accordingly, including the asymmetry effect into the portfolio provides an investor an additional benefit different from the skewness effect. Naturally, going long on the commodities with the lowest IE and shorting those with the highest IE results in a profitable trading strategy. A strategy that takes a long position in the bottom seven commodities with the lowest IE in the previous month and shorts the top seven commodities with the highest IE achieved a 4.36% annual return with a corresponding Sharpe ratio of 0.58. Additionally, it can serve as a hedge to the stock portfolio because of its negative correlation with the stock market.

Fundamental reason

A new measure IE that asymmetric strategy relies on uses the difference between upside and downside return probabilities to capture the degree of asymmetry. The greater the measure, the greater the upside potential of the asset return. Typical risk-averse investors prefer extreme gains and avoid extreme losses. Consequently, they bid up the prices of assets with a high chance of extreme gains and pay a lower price for assets with a high likelihood of extreme losses. As a result, the high (low) IE assets become overvalued (undervalued), and their subsequent returns are lower (higher). Therefore, the asymmetric strategy goes short on the most overvalued commodities with the highest IE and long on the most undervalued commodities with the lowest IE. Besides, the correlation analysis between the proposed strategy and the corresponding skewness portfolio indicates a low positive correlation with a correlation coefficient of 0.46. Even though the skewness and asymmetry effects are related, the correlation is not that high, and both effects form distinct trading strategies.

Get Premium Strategy Ideas & Pro Reporting

  • Unlocked Screener & 300+ Advanced Charts
  • 700+ uncommon trading strategy ideas
  • New strategies on a bi-weekly basis
  • 2000+ links to academic research papers
  • 500+ out-of-sample backtests
  • Design multi-factor multi-asset portfolios
Markets Traded
commodities

Backtest period from source paper
1991-2021

Confidence in anomaly's validity
Strong

Indicative Performance
4.36%

Notes to Confidence in Anomaly's Validity

Notes to Indicative Performance

Table 1, Portfolio 7, Annualized return


Period of Rebalancing
Monthly

Estimated Volatility
7.53%

Notes to Period of Rebalancing

Notes to Estimated Volatility

Table 1, Portfolio 7, Annualized volatility


Number of Traded Instruments
22

Maximum Drawdown
-29.03%

Notes to Number of Traded Instruments

22 commodity futures, namely: soybean oil, corn, cocoa, cotton, feeder cattle, gold, copper, heating oil, coffee, live cattle, lean hogs, natural gas, oats, orange juice, palladium, platinum, soybean, sugar, silver, soybean meal, wheat, and crude oil


Notes to Maximum drawdown

Table 1, Portfolio 7, Maximal drawdown


Complexity Evaluation
Moderately complex strategy

Sharpe Ratio
0.58

Notes to Complexity Evaluation

Region
Global

Financial instruments
futures

Keywordssmart beta
Simple trading strategy

The investment universe consists of 22 commodity futures, namely: soybean oil, corn, cocoa, cotton, feeder cattle, gold, copper, heating oil, coffee, live cattle, lean hogs, natural gas, oats, orange juice, palladium, platinum, soybean, sugar, silver, soybean meal, wheat, and crude oil. Firstly, at the beginning of each month, construct the asymmetry measure (IE) for each commodity based on the latest 260 daily returns using the following formula (the formula originally consists of theoretical density and integrals, however the solution is simple when empirical distribution is utilized): IE = (number of trading days when the daily return is greater than the average plus two standard deviations) – (number of trading days when the daily return is smaller than the average minus two standard deviations). Then rank the commodities according to their IE. Buy the bottom seven commodities with the lowest IE in the previous month and sell the top seven commodities with the highest IE in the previous month. Weigh the portfolio equally and rebalance monthly.

Hedge for stocks during bear markets

Yes - When the monthly S&P 500 return was negative the average monthly
S&P 500 return was -3.50%. However, the average monthly return of the IE Portfolio 7 was 0.50%. Based on regression of the Portfolio 7 returns on the S&P 500 returns, there is a negative slope coefficient of β = -0.04 (t-stat = -1.53). The correlation between Portfolio 7 and S&P 500 returns varies over time with an average correlation coefficient of ρ = -0.08 (tstat = -1.53). Figure 4 shows that the negative relationship becomes more significant during stock market declines like in the early 2000s, 2007, and 2020.

Source paper
Out-of-sample strategy's implementation/validation in QuantConnect's framework (chart+statistics+code)
Other papers

Subscribe for Newsletter

Be first to know, when we publish new content


    logo
    The Encyclopedia of Quantitative Trading Strategies

    Log in

    SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER AND GET:
    - bi-weekly research insights -
    - tips on new trading strategies -
    - notifications about offers & promos -
    Subscribe