Prediction markets

In the high-stakes arena of prediction markets, a counterintuitive pattern emerges: retail traders who correctly pick winners more than half the time still lose money, while automated traders with coin-flip accuracy pocket nine-figure profits. Using 222 million prediction market tradeswith directly observable terminal payoffs, the paper “Who Profits from Prediction? Execution, Not Information” presents a clean answer to why it is so. The authors decompose trader returns into a directional component and an execution component, revealing that the execution component, not the directional component, determines which trader types earn positive returns. 

This study examines the profitability of mean-reversion trading strategies applied to binary outcome contracts on Polymarket, the world’s largest decentralized prediction market platform. We analyze three distinct contracts representing varying risk profiles: a quasi-risk-free instrument (No to “Will Jesus Christ return in 2025?”) and two high-yield speculative contracts (No to “Will China invade Taiwan in 2025?” and “Will the US confirm that aliens exist in 2025?”). Using high-frequency price data sampled at 10-minute intervals over approximately one year, we implement a parameterized mean-reversion framework across twelve strategy variants, testing robustness under varying liquidity constraints and transaction cost assumptions. Our findings reveal that while mean-reversion signals generate substantial alpha under passive limit-order execution (zero-spread scenario), strategy performance degrades significantly when more aggressive market orders are accounted for.

Prediction markets are financial platforms where participants trade contracts linked to future events, with prices reflecting collective probabilities. While these markets efficiently aggregate information, systematic inefficiencies create trading opportunities. Notable strategies include inter- and intra-market arbitrage, exploiting price differences across platforms or mispricing within a single market. Behavioral biases, such as the longshot bias, lead traders to overvalue underdogs and undervalue favorites, while bookmakers may manipulate odds to mislead naive participants. Experienced traders can exploit these patterns to secure profits. This article reviews common systematic edges in prediction markets, illustrates their practical application, and highlights the potential for profitable trading.