Smart beta

The year 2024 is nearly behind us, so it’s an excellent time for a short recapitulation. In the previous 12 months, we have been busy again (as usual) and have published over 70 short analyses of academic papers and our own research articles. The end of the year is a good opportunity to summarize 10 of them, which were the most popular (based on the Google Analytics ranking). The top 10 is diverse, as usual; once again, we hope that you may find something you have not read yet …

Active Share is a popular metric used to gauge how actively managed a portfolio is compared to its benchmark, but its predictive power for fund performance is questionable. Our research suggests that high Active Share often reflects exposure to systematic equity factors rather than genuine stock-picking skill. Additionally, inaccuracies in benchmark selection can distort the metric’s insights, making it unreliable as a standalone measure. A more effective approach is to conduct a factor analysis of alpha to better understand a manager’s performance and true sources of over/underperformance.

Our article explores a simple mean reversion trading strategy applied to FX futures, focusing on identifying undervalued and overvalued currencies to generate returns. Using FX futures rather than spot rates allows for the inclusion of interest rate differentials, simplifying the analysis. The strategy employs two position-sizing methods—linear and exponential—both rebalanced monthly based on currency deviations from their mean. While the linear method offers stability, its returns are limited. In contrast, the exponential method, despite higher risk and deeper drawdowns, ultimately delivers stronger growth and better overall performance by leveraging the mean reversion tendencies of FX pairs.

In this article, we explore the historical performance of sector momentum strategies and examine how their alpha has diminished over time. By analyzing the underlying causes behind this decline, we identify key factors contributing to the underperformance. Most importantly, we introduce an enhanced approach to sector momentum, demonstrating how this solution significantly improves the performance of an ETF sector momentum strategy, making it once again an effective tool for systematic investors.

Equal-weighted benchmark portfolios are sometimes overshadowed by the more popular market capitalization benchmarks but are still popular and often used in practice. One of the advantages of equal-weighted portfolios is that academic research shows that in the long term, they tend to outperform their market-cap-weighted peers, mainly due to positive loadings on well-known factor premiums like size and value. So, if equal weighting outperforms market-cap weighting (in the long term), what options do we have if we want to outperform equal weighting? A recent paper by Cirulli and Walker comes to our aid with an interesting proposal …

One of the main reasons why the Pragmatic Asset Allocation Model was designed is to give investors a tax-efficient possibility to invest in a global equity portfolio with a lower risk than the passive buy&hold approach. Therefore, the PAA model is not the “absolute return” model but rather the tactical model that prefers to invest in the equity risk premium and move to the hedging portfolio (gold, treasuries, or cash), only for short periods and only when it’s absolutely necessary. We use price trend+momentum indicators and yield curve inversion as signals for such situations when (based on the past data) there is a higher probability of recessions and equity bear markets. What is unusual in the current situation is the length of time that the YC is inverted (19 months at the moment), which makes it the 2nd longest YC inversion in the last 100 years, and we are analyzing the implications for the PAA model.