Is Trend Still Your Friend?: A Microstructural Account of the Demise of Short-Term Trend-Following
Trend following was one of the most persistent anomalies in finance for nearly two centuries, yet its performance deteriorated sharply after the 2008 financial crisis. An analysis of approximately 100 liquid futures contracts from 1995 to 2025 shows that this decline is highly selective. The decisive factor is not asset class, liquidity, market electronification, or strategy crowding, but volatility-normalized tick size. After 2008, trend-following profits collapsed almost entirely on small-tick contracts across all signal horizons, while remaining largely intact on large-tick contracts. This finding suggests that modern trend-following portfolios are fundamentally split into two distinct regimes governed by market microstructure rather than traditional asset classifications.